Skip to content
Independent reporting

Op-Ed Claims Democrats Can Now Trigger Electoral College Compact

Share X Facebook Email

A Western Journal opinion piece argues Democrats now hold enough state “trifectas” to pass an “Electoral College Compact” (ECC) that would direct participating states to award their electoral votes to the national popular‑vote winner once member states total a majority of electoral votes. The article frames the ECC as a way to sidestep the current Electoral College system.

What the piece says the ECC would do

According to the article, the ECC is a state‑to‑state agreement that would activate only when states representing at least 270 electoral votes have joined, at which point those states would cast their electoral votes for the national popular‑vote leader. The author describes this as a “joint initiative between states.”

The five risks the author lists

The op‑ed contends there are five main problems: (1) the assumption that the Electoral College favors Republicans is temporary and could cut against Democrats in the future; (2) the ECC is “probably unconstitutional,” including under the Constitution’s Compact Clause; (3) there is “no such thing as a ‘national popular vote’” for states to rely on, because some states have used elector slates not tied to specific candidates; (4) the plan does not eliminate the possibility of faithless electors and could increase the incentive for them; and (5) it could produce disputed or aberrant outcomes that the author says would “shake the Republic to its core.”

The crisis scenario sketched

“Under the ECC, any close election would become an immediate national crisis,” the article asserts, predicting simultaneous contests over ballots and procedures across many states. Citing changes since 2000 such as mail‑in voting, same‑day registration, provisional ballots, and ballot‑curing processes, the piece argues these would multiply disputes. It also singles out Democratic election lawyer Marc Elias as emblematic of aggressive postelection litigation. The author further claims some states, such as California, already take weeks to finalize results and argues it would be impossible to produce uncontested results within “36 days,” which the piece says federal law requires.

Third parties and ‘minority presidents’

The article contends the ECC would encourage independent or third‑party bids by rewarding a simple national plurality and, without runoffs or ranked‑choice voting baked into the pact, could elect a president with far below majority support. Citing Ross Perot’s 1992 run, the author argues the current Electoral College deters well‑funded independent candidacies, while the ECC could let a candidate with roughly 35 percent of the vote prevail.

States exiting mid‑campaign

The piece also warns states could withdraw from the compact during a campaign, abruptly shifting candidates’ strategies. It posits a scenario in which a Democratic‑leaning state exits if polling suggests the party’s nominee would fare better under the traditional Electoral College than a national popular vote tally.

The author’s bottom line

The op‑ed concludes that courts may have to intervene. “It is up to the Supreme Court to save us,” the author writes, predicting that Democrats would respond by “beating the court packing drum louder.”

Editor’s note: This report summarizes an opinion essay published by The Western Journal. Kingdom Watch News has not independently verified the legal or factual claims described above.

Share X Facebook Email

The Kingdom Watch Brief

The day’s essential headlines, without the noise.

A concise briefing delivered directly to your inbox.

Free to join. Unsubscribe any time.

Powered by Reach Response